The Vanishing Gentleman

Mixed Messages & the Lost Ideal - Part 1

by Dana Raye Barnaby

Part 1 of 2

We are no longer living in a world of clarity. Not in communication. Not in gender. Not in love.

The idea of a gentleman is fading - not because men no longer care to be respectful or kind, but because they don’t know where they fit in anymore. The rules keep shifting. The expectations collide, and the voices shouting from all sides - on screens, on stages, on social feeds - don’t always align with what’s actually happening in people’s hearts.

I feel I need to say this clearly, right from the start - this essay is not about blame. It’s about the growing confusion - and the quiet emotional cost - for those of us still trying to do the right thing in a culture that no longer agrees on what that is.

I feel lucky that I grew up before the internet. Before swiping, TikTok, filters and online dating apps, before it became normal to say “I think we’re dating the same guy” and share screenshots of text messages like war trophies.

I had role models, family conversations at the dinner table, board games and sometimes just a wooden stick that imagination turned into a magic wand, baseball bat, or an orchestra baton.  These were real moments where we learned how to interact, play, become socially aware and most importantly learn to share.

Today’s youth doesn’t have that same foundation. They’re learning about relationships, attraction, and gender roles from whatever shows up in their feed.

Worried for Our Future

What are the youth supposed to make of this world?

We tell boys and girls to respect each other - and we should. But we don’t explain what that means anymore. We tell young boys not to objectify women, even while young women turn to platforms like Instagram, TikTok, and OnlyFans that reward sexualized content with attention, engagement, and in many cases, massive wealth. The mixed messages are overwhelming.

If you’re a 15-year-old boy watching this unfold in real-time, what are you supposed to believe? What does respect look like when the very system that celebrates women also commodifies them?

And what happens when those same boys grow into men - only to be met with a new set of contradictions? They’ve been told to be softer, gentler, more emotionally aware - yet also ambitious, confident, and assertive. They’re encouraged to lead, but warned not to take up too much space. They’re told masculinity must evolve, but are rarely shown what that evolution actually looks like.

And then, in professional circles - on film sets, in writers’ rooms, in interviews - they hear things like, “It was so refreshing to work without all that testosterone,” or “It was just so nice to finally have a woman in charge.” Comments that are often meant to uplift women (and rightfully so), but which also quietly suggest that male presence itself is a problem - unwelcome by default.

Where does that leave us?

Worse yet, where does it leave the idea of love? Of connection? Of building something together that isn’t just transactional, or curated for likes, or designed to avoid vulnerability at all costs?

We’re creating a world where men are afraid to approach women, where women assume every man is a threat, and where ghosting has replaced honesty because it’s easier to disappear than to speak the truth. This isn’t just changing connection. It’s rewiring how we see one another.

And no one is winning.

The Village is Gone

There’s a scene in life - and in art - that’s becoming harder to find: the moment where a boy becomes a man. Not through aggression or bravado, but through guidance - through love, wisdom, and the watchful eyes of a community that cares enough to shape him.

But today, that community is gone. In its place, we’ve handed children a device, unlimited access, and zero mentorship.

In the powerful Netflix series Adolescence, co-creator and actor Steven Graham spoke about this very issue in an interview with Jimmy Kimmel. He said, “Kids used to play outside. Now they have access to everything. Every type of content - good, bad, violent, sexual - is just sitting in their hands.” You can see the weariness in his voice, not from judgment, but from concern. The series itself is a raw, unfiltered portrayal of how unsupervised digital exposure shapes the identities of young boys and girls before they’ve had a chance to form their own.

Graham makes a simple, haunting observation: “It takes a village to raise a child. But we don’t have villages anymore.”

Instead, we have algorithms. We have influencers. We have girls being rewarded for flaunting their bodies and boys being mocked for not knowing how to talk to them. We have dating apps designed to make everyone disposable. We have parents too overwhelmed to monitor every feed. We have social norms that reward the most extreme behavior - not the most honorable.

And into this digital wilderness, we’ve sent millions of young adults - alone, unmentored, and confused - trying to decode what it means to be good when all they see is what gets attention.

It’s not about wanting to turn back the clock. It’s about asking - what happens to the men who are still trying to do it right? Where do they belong in this new landscape?

The answer isn’t to silence women. The answer isn’t to shame men. The answer is to admit that we’ve lost the map. And before we can find our way back to mutual respect, we need to start an honest conversation about how we got so lost in the first place.

Because without that conversation, the idea of the gentleman doesn’t just vanish—it gets buried under blame, resentment, and misunderstanding.

And without the gentleman, we risk losing something bigger than tradition.

We risk losing connection itself…

Part 2: Redefining the Role

Coming soon. In part two, we’ll explore what’s really at stake - and how rebuilding empathy, identity, and respect might just lead us back to love, companionship, and peace.

Thank you for taking the time to join me on this journey of reflection and storytelling. If these words have resonated, you might enjoy my second series of essays called, The Art of Living. 

Subscribe today to continue our conversation. Together, we can explore the timeless art of living thoughtfully and graciously. Your support means the world to me.

Home